The Sublime and the Beautiful

When Nicholas Penny became director of the National Gallery in 2008 he promised an end to the cult of the blockbuster exhibition and proposed instead more focused shows that would display the gallery’s considerable holdings in new ways. Devotion by Design: Italian Altarpieces before 1500 is a perfect example of what he had in mind. This is a scholarly — but not unapproachable — examination of a rich genre: as well as the numerous little-known artists represented are many of the Renaissance’s great names — Duccio, Masaccio, Piero della Francesca, Leonardo and Michelangelo. 

The exhibition serves above all as a reminder that many of the pictures we are used to seeing in isolation were made for a very different context, and one that would have transformed them utterly. Indeed the show itself is as much about that context-whether the layout of churches or the spectacular gilded settings that were central to their effect-as the images themselves. One of the National’s best-loved paintings, for example — Piero della Francesca’s Baptism of Christ from the 1450s — now has a 19th-century tabernacle frame (with pilasters and an arch mimicking an architectural setting) and stands alone as a unified piece. When it was painted, however, it was designed simply as the central panel in a complicated Gothic ensemble that included 15 other paintings showing various saints and episodes from their lives that were the work of a lesser artist, Matteo de Giovanni. As it was initially viewed, Piero’s quietly contemplative scene had to fight for attention in a riot of gilding, carving, finials and competing images. 

In fact the name altarpiece itself is somewhat misleading. It assumes these sculpture-painting hybrids were linked to the high altar but they were also hung in side chapels and aisles and some were even painted directly on to walls. And nor did they have any liturgical legitimacy: canon law stipulated the presence on the altar of a crucifix and two candles, and other items took their place there too — a pyx, chalice, paten, missal and so on — but altarpieces had no official role in the celebration of mass. Gradually, however, they came to be adopted largely as a theatrical backdrop against which the priest would raise the consecrated host and thus, with their numinous imagery, aid the congregation’s   understanding of the moment of transubstantiation. They were not intended to act as icons for either veneration as holy objects or as a means of intercession with God himself.

The narrative of the exhibition starts with the first polyptychs (multi-panel constructions) in the early 14th century and examines how they were superseded in the next century by the pala (a single picture with the saints that used to be in separate panels joining the Virgin and Child in the main image). Along the way there are discussions of the predella panels that supported the main work and usually showed scenes from the life of the altarpiece’s tutelary saint and the extraordinarily complicated carved wooden frames which were seen as works of art in their own right. For example, Michelangelo was paid 60 ducats for his Entombment (1500-1501), while the frame-maker received 50 ducats. 

The fact that so many altarpieces were subsequently dismembered and their panels distributed around the world adds an element of detective and forensic work to an already fascinating exhibition.

Religion is also the subject of the National’s second summer show, but this time in its post-Enlightenment guise of Nature. Forests, Rocks, Torrents is a selection of 45 Norwegian and Swiss 19th-century landscapes from the collection of Asbjørn Lunde. It seems at first glance a recondite subject but it offers a glimpse into an unexpected corner of European Romanticism and the work of a group of little-known but beguiling painters.

The early 19th century was the age of national landscape painting because, at a time of revolution and political instability, it offered painters and their audiences a way of reassessing their own country’s characteristics and place in the world. Topography, whether British, German or North American, was as individual as a fingerprint and Norwegian and Swiss artists were no more immune to this pervading mood than were Turner or Caspar David Friedrich. 

The two countries shared physical similarities that were meat and drink to painters-mountains, vertiginous views, frothing rivers, hanging woods — but were in all other respects opposites. Switzerland was independent, central and prosperous while Norway was a poor Swedish chattel, sat on the serrated edge of the Continent. Where Norway was rich was in the drama of its landscape, and painting it was one way of joining Europe’s elite. 

While many of the pictures on display are straightforward exercises in the Sublime some of the painters deserve wider recognition, among them Johan Christian Dahl — a friend of Friedrich’s and the father of Norwegian painting — pupil Thomas Fearnley and Caspar Wolf. But two artists in particular stand out: the Norwegian Peder Balke (1804-1887) and the Swiss Alexandre Calame (1810-1864). Their work has an intensity that belongs to a higher, mystical stratum of Romantic art. Calame’s pictures combine microscopic geological exactitude with the most sweeping of atmospheric effects while Balke’s forgo reality altogether and replace it with a Wagnerian moodiness. 

Balke trained as a scene painter and the pictures he created after a visit to the North Cape in 1832 condense the techniques of his training — all thin paint and scrapings and wipings —to pocket size. His pictures of raging seas and distant mountains thrum with the howl of winds and the crash of Arctic seas; they may be near monochromatic but the effect is hallucinatory. Balke’s career died in his own lifetime but his depiction of nature was as idiosyncratic as Samuel Palmer’s in this country and this exhibition offers an overdue introduction to a distinctive painter.

An autumn note

“For many, the end of this uneasy year cannot come quickly enough”

An ordinary killing

Ian Cobain’s book uses the killing of Millar McAllister to paint a meticulous portrait of the Troubles

Greater—not wiser

John Mullan elucidates the genius of Charles Dickens
Search