Better Off Out Of It

'Europe's economic and commercial importance to the UK will collapse in the 21st century'

Tim Congdon

David Cameron has promised that in 2017 a newly elected Conservative government would hold an In/Out referendum on our membership of the European Union. What will the world economy look like four years from now and, in particular, how vital will our trading relationship with the EU be to us? It will be 42 years after the 1975 referendum, the first and so far only popular vote on the UK’s position in “the European construction”. Suppose that in 2017 the British people vote to stay in and that a similar 42-year wait follows before the next testing of public opinion. Can anything useful be said today about the world of 2059? 

To answer the first question let us consult the website of the International Monetary Fund. As the data there may come as a shock to our eurocentric politicians, it needs to be emphasised that the IMF is a good, unbiased source. The IMF is far from perfect in its behaviour or forward vision, but it is at least well-informed, objective and impartial relative to most of the alternative authorities. The key message is that the importance of the European Union in the world economy has declined, is declining and will decline further. (2017 is the last year for which it made projections in its October 2012 World Economic Outlook publication and the related database.)  

In the last few decades the EU has been the dominant market for British exporters, being typically the destination for between 50 and 60 per cent of all the goods and services that we sell abroad. This is hardly surprising as Britain is geographically part of Europe, and the EU in the 1980s and 1990s accounted for a high share of world output. In 1980 the EU’s share of world output was almost a third, at 31.1 per cent. In the early 1990s, as the plans for the single currency were being advanced, it still represented over a quarter of the world economy. 

However, its subsequent fall from grace has been abrupt and severe. According to the IMF, the EU’s share of world output last year was 18.8 per cent and in 2017 will be down to 17.1 per cent. Its planners may have dreamt that the new single currency would have replaced the dollar as the world’s leading currency by the 2020s. But the eurozone’s share of world output has dropped even faster than that of the EU. Last year it was 13.3 per cent and in 2017 the IMF expects it to be down to 11.9 per cent. The eurozone will never overtake the US economically, while the dollar will continue to outshine the euro as an international currency. 

Given these trends, the EU’s role as a market for our products has weakened. At present our exports of goods to the EU and the rest of the world are roughly the same, while our exports of services to the rest of the world are probably above those to the EU. (The geographical composition of services trade is more difficult to track.) Over the four years to the referendum there can be little doubt that the rest of the world will overtake the EU as the UK’s largest market, a fact which will be highlighted by those in favour of withdrawal. 

The debate on EU membership is for the current generation, but not only for us. In such fundamental matters we are custodians for our children and grandchildren. So what about 2059? Worthwhile estimates of national outputs do not extend to 50 years from now. However, the UN does have a team of statisticians which prepares demographic projections for almost 100 years. Although the population forecasts are beset by uncertainty and open to debate, they are as authoritative as any available. 

In recognition of the difficulties, the UN statisticians offer three cases (a high-, middle- and low-variant) for discussion. Let us take the middle variant for simplicity. When the UK joined the Common Market in 1973, Europe without Russia (then of course still the hegemonic power in Eastern Europe) accounted for more than 15 per cent of the world’s population. But, according to the UN, by 2059 that figure will be down to 6 per cent, while the citizens of the three big Western European powers with a long-term EU commitment — Germany, France and Italy — will be only 2 per cent of the world’s population. The equivalents of Merkel, Hollande and Monti will matter to the politics of their nations in 2059, and they will matter to us as one of their immediate neighbours. All the same, 98 per cent of the world’s people will be living in other countries. 

The world is changing rapidly. The inevitable result of those changes is that Europe’s economic and commercial importance to us will collapse in the 21st century. Of course, free trade between the UK and the EU is to our benefit, and we should try to maintain that if we leave the EU. But the EU’s significance in the world at large is falling sharply, and the possible 2017 referendum and the growing debate on our EU membership need to be seen in that perspective. 

An autumn note

“For many, the end of this uneasy year cannot come quickly enough”

An ordinary killing

Ian Cobain’s book uses the killing of Millar McAllister to paint a meticulous portrait of the Troubles

Greater—not wiser

John Mullan elucidates the genius of Charles Dickens
Search