You are here:   Reputations >  Overrated > Overrated: Nassim Nicholas Taleb
 

The padding that fattens the Black Swan up from a chapter to a book is worse than irrelevant fluff; it is angry, righteous and self-congratulatory. It also hints at a flimsy grasp of the non-financial subjects he strays on to and of the philosophy of science. 

Taleb's scepticism is not restricted to the chance of very unlikely events. He thinks that we generally know less than we think, and that economics and much of modern science is bunkum. The Nobel Prize for economics and its winners cause him special psychic pain. At a conference in Mexico in 2009 (which you can see on YouTube) he claimed that the supposed knowledge of modern doctors has made no contribution to extending our life expectancy. The human body, like the weather and the economy, is too complex to be amenable to science. As evidence, he claimed that when elective surgery is briefly suspended (perhaps because of a strike), death rates do not increase. I will not insult you by pointing to the well-known facts that contradict this scepticism about modern medicine, nor explain how Taleb's "evidence" could be correct without supporting his conclusion. 

Taleb's extra-curricular absurdities are often expressed in the style of a post-modernist literature student. He talks about "narratives", "reductive categories" and "what lies on the other side of the veil of opacity". He thinks that claims about the origins of the universe or the reality of death need no evidence when uttered by the religious, because they are using holy terms rather than scientific ones. He thereby endorses the relativists' fantasy that a mere choice of jargon can absolve you of all intellectual obligations. 

He has now published a book of aphorisms, The Bed of Procrustes, heavily promoted on the BBC Today programme. A collection of aphorisms would usually be assembled by a fan after a lifetime of brilliant work and pithy nuggets of wisdom. But Taleb cannot wait, nor rely on others fully to appreciate his wisdom. So he has delivered his own collection of freshly-cooked nuggets. It is not only the vanity of the enterprise but the aphorisms themselves that are excruciating. They reveal Taleb's obsession with a handful of topics, but mainly with himself: erudition (that's him), charm (him), wisdom (him), nerds (not him), the internet (which is for nerds, not him), philosophers (him), suckers (not him), hard work (which is not for geniuses like him), paid academics (not him, except in fact) and the great men of antiquity (of whom he is a late example). If only it were true.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Daryll
April 23rd, 2014
5:04 PM
Idiotic. Even if you have tossed the coin 100 times the probability of the next throw is 1/2 even if the previous 100 were all heads, and that's not accounting for dropping the coin down a drain or suffering a sudden aneurism as a result of living in your left brain instead of the messy dynamic real world. - Doing some maths about what's likely to happen next does not tell you what will happen next. The more we build upon blocks of false certainty based on conceptual models the more a collapse is inevitable - the point of the book to some degree is that the collapse ws not a black swan - it was entirely predictable because we live in a world full of people like you lot - conditioned by Acadaemia you make the world static, certain and simple to fit into your reductive categories of comple equivalence. I think you missed the point spectacularly.

Marty Brandon
February 23rd, 2014
3:02 PM
I'd just finished the first two chapters of the The Black Swan, and had a growing feeling of nauseating postmodernism. Thanks to this article and the video link posted by Fabian, I believe I can skip the rest of the book. Thank you both for saving me a bit of time.

Levi
January 26th, 2014
11:01 PM
Uh, why is Taleb's distinction between risk and uncertainty being attributed to him? University of Chicago economist Frank Knight worked all of this out, and quite famously, back in the 1920's.

Pallab Basu
October 31st, 2013
6:10 AM
Whyte defending science is like pope defending Islam. Whyte does not have a clue on how scientific method works and why Taleb is against economics. It is very common for scientists to fall into "action bias", where people overdo things to think they are improving situation, when in reality nothing is chaning. However with all its error and biases, modern science is a self-correcting data-driven mechine, which improves over time. An economists can hardly say the same for his subject.

jc
October 25th, 2013
1:10 PM
I have read both the book by Taleb and some of the popular writings of Jamie Whyte. I am connsiderably more impressed by Taleb than Whyte, though can undertsand why some might find Taleb's style not to their tastes. He uses wide-ranging analogies in a popular book, some of which can be misconstrued or are obscure. However,Taleb's argument is considerably more subtle than Jamie Whyte seems to appreciate. It is partly spelled out in The Black Swan but more explicit in Fooled by Randomness. The idea of a 'black swan' is an event which comes out of nowhere and proves that our previous model of the world was false. That their should be such things is a severe challenge to the methods used in financial markets, where practitioners use statistical models of financial behaviour and estimate the parameters based on past observations. This is a perfectly valid approach, argues Taleb, if whatever is being nmodelled follows a process that can be approximated to the Normal distribution. A great many phenomena can but Taleb argues, extremely convincingly that others cannot. Crucially, it is not possible to determine the parameters of the distribution however many observations one takes as one single 'black swan' changes everything. Taleb then explains why such distributions exist, the mathematics of them and how they relate to the real world. It seems clear to me that Jamie Whyte has no appreciation of this-hence his review. As an aside, I have read some of Whytes popular articles where he touts the merits of a philosophical approach to real world problems. I was impressed as they seemed an excellent parody of eroneous reasoning.After a while, it dawned on me that,far from being works of comedy, Whyte was for real. Reviews are of course subjective, but I feel Taleb is more worthy of detaile reading.

Mark Tsomondo
April 24th, 2013
11:04 PM
Taleb is courageously onto "something" that eludes, and perhaps now, offends, guru prognostications and prescriptions. He warns us not to be suckers for naive economic rationalizations, including new high-sounding sophistry. In my view, Taleb is a rare thought-democrat, a naked philosopher, when it comes to the appreciation of diverse and often "unpublishable" native knowledge systems, including Brooklyn Fat Tony's wisdom. Not many Geologists that I have met are comfortable with the idea that over 80% of what became the largest gold mines in Zimbabwe were founded on sites of pre-colonial mining by "native" people, who, un-enamoured by geological theory, went about the practice of discovering and mining gold for trade to fend off hunger. Taleb would acknowledge this pay-off of exchanging gold for food.

Fabian
November 26th, 2012
4:11 PM
I wholeheartedly agree with the author's sentiment. Just listen to Taleb's 5 minute stream of bullshit at the said conference in Mexico: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H11t5zBd3fU - it is painful...

nrt1
November 25th, 2012
11:11 AM
For Jamie Whyte to take someone to task for vanity really is Black Kettle rather than Black Swan

Anonymous
November 24th, 2012
7:11 PM
Taleb does not argue that the financial crisis was a black swan. He maintains it was entirely predictable (just a matter of when, not if). But of course, he's arrogant. Let's count a management consultant to provide insight; that's surely a genius move.

John Perez
December 31st, 2011
8:12 AM
I think over three quarters of the Taleb book reviews on Amazon make the same observation about his arrogance as well as the lack of real content in his books. Everyone agrees.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.