You are here:   Blogs >Jessica Duchen > Shock Win in Warsaw
Standpoint Blogs
Jessica Duchen
Thursday 21st October 2010
Shock Win in Warsaw

And the winner of the 2010 International Chopin Competition in Warsaw is: Yulianna Avdeeva, 25, from Russia, who becomes the first woman to triumph there since Martha Argerich 45 years ago. Lukas Geniusas of Lithuania/Russia, 20, and Ingolf Wunder, 25, of Austria won joint second prize, Daniil Trifonov of Russia third and the pianist who according to general buzz via the internet seemed to be hot favourite earlier on, Evgeni Bozhanov of Bulgaria, pulled in fourth. Francois Dumont from France won fifth. No sixth prize was awarded: the sole Pole, Mr Wakarecy, won nothing.

Critical reports before the results were announced had suggested that Wunder would win, with John Allison, who's valiantly attended the whole shebang, writing: ‘Wunder has got everything one wants to hear in a Chopin player. His is a very patrician, aristocratic kind of sound. He’s got an absolutely beautiful sense of tone and huge musical imagination, coupled with incredible virtuosity.’

Now, I have no idea how these decisions are made. The jury was large and distinguished, with Andrzej Jasinski, Zimerman's only teacher, as chairman. Argerich was there, Bella Davidovich, Nelson Freire and Fou Ts'ong, among others. It's not a team whose judgment I'd wish to disregard.

The invitation to vote online for the winner doesn't seem to have had much to do with the result, and didn't depend on you actually having heard anybody play (you just point and click): this vote brought in Wunder in top place with 26%, Trifonov with 23% and Bozhanov with 12.5%. Avdeeva trailed with just 9.1%. 

Below, part of the lucky winner's prize concerto: this is the slow movement of the Chopin E minor. Now, as my other 'alf puts it, "when you're used to Krystian Zimerman, everything else sounds s***". But I'm sorry to say I dislike this performance quite intensely. I find it extremely in-yer-face, ridiculously loud and not co-ordinated with the orchestra nearly well enough. It seems to have a lot to do with Ms Avdeeva and not a lot to do with Chopin's hushed nocturnal musings... What do you think? Would you have given this top prize in a top contest? Listening to her Polonaise-Fantaisie, I've had a similar reaction: she lumps and thumps the hell out of it without any apparent value on tone quality, and with splashy rhetorically-out-of-sync hand effects passing for expression. (You can find it on Youtube if you really want to.) And the general response to her win seems to be less than ecstatic, to put it mildly.

I have the impression that something has gone wrong.

Now, here is Ingolf Wunder, playing the Andante Spianato and Grand Polonaise in Round 2. This, my friends, qualifies as very good, stylish and idiomatic Chopin playing: listen to the detail, the phrasing, the elegance, the rubato, the structural awareness.

And after the Wunder, the Genius...This is Lukas Geniusas with the Barcarolle, from the second round - possibly my favourite so far, the only one who's approached some sense of mystical atmosphere, though even then I'd have some holes to pick here and there...

But of course, I wasn't in Warsaw and frankly I'm rather glad, as I've heard two young pianists in Britain this past week who can play the living daylights out of any of these guys. They are both on the BBC New Generations scheme. I hope that this project survives the 16% cutback at the Beeb, because it is incredibly valuable as an alternative career-builder for the most gifted of the younger generation, by-passing the rough, tumble and nonsense of these competition bullfights.

If you were at the Chopin Competition, do write in and let us know what you thought about it all. 

Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Tom Hubschman
September 16th, 2011
9:09 PM
Have to disagree. She's the best thing to happen to Chopin in my lifetime. No one else made his music come alive for me or made me feel what it is really about: the stuff of Greek tragedy.

Santiago Restrepo
October 25th, 2010
11:10 PM
If I had to pick between these three my first place would go for the lady. I sincerely would not award anything to the other two. Their playing could be technically acomplished but they not convey any emotions. I think you are right when you point that the ensemble with the orchestra is horrible. I found Mr Wit to blame. He seems incompetent to a degree that could be called plain dishonesty. It looks as if he were sabotaging Miss Avdeeva, specially when you think that he has to know this pieces by heart. It is easy to see Miss Avdeeva discomfort when she tries to make eye contact with the members of the orchestra. Mr Wit beat is stiff, ambiguous, clumsy and, ironically, witless. I found Miss Avdeeva playing moving at times and found her coping admirably well given such incompetent playing on the orchestra.

Terese Prasnick
October 25th, 2010
11:10 PM
CORRECTION TO MY PRIOR COMMENTS: Today they NIFC posted scores of participants from all rounds on the competition web site. They must be feeling pressure.

Terese Prasnick
October 25th, 2010
10:10 PM
I spent too much time following this competition both Internet and then live in the hall for Round 2. You captured my reservations about Avdeeva's playing exactly. But she was a strong crowd-pleaser each round in the hall. For me, Wunder was the solid choice for performance maturity, and the Chopin idiom. And his concerto was outstanding, expecially the poetry of 2nd movement. Bozhanov was presenting himself on Chopin, but again in an experienced exciting manner. Geniusas grew every round. What went wrong? If you piece together interviews afterwards, sounds like the judges abandoned the points that accompany their yes/no scoring. And BTW, I have never seen judges address a contestant's specific shortcomings in the press before - sounds defensive at the performer's expense. I wish the all of the pianists who were ruled out prematurely in each round all of the best in their career.

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
About Jessica Duchen

Jessica Duchen is a music journalist and the author of four novels, two biographies and several stage works. She writes regularly for The Independent and BBC Music Magazine. Her latest novel, Songs of Triumphant Love, is published by Hodder.

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics