You are here:   Blogs >Joshua Rozenberg > Hell on Earth
Standpoint Blogs
 
 
Joshua Rozenberg
Friday 2nd July 2010
Hell on Earth

Two activists accused of conspiring to cause some £200,000-worth of damage to a weapons factory were cleared today on the judge's direction. Five more were cleared earlier this week and one was found not guilty on the directions of the judge, George Bathurst Norman.

Christopher Osmond, 30, Elijah Smith, 42, and six other anti-war campaigners admitted they broke into the Brighton headquarters of EDO MBM in the early hours of January 17 last year, sabotaging equipment worth in the region of £200,000.

During their three-week trial at Hove Crown Court it was said they were acting with "lawful excuse" to prevent further alleged war crimes being committed by Israel against Gaza.

Section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Damage Act 1971 defines "lawful excuse" to include protecting property. This is clearly designed for the sort of case where a fire-fighter breaks into a building to put out a fire.

Today Osmond, from Brighton, East Sussex, and Smith, from Bristol, were acquitted of conspiracy to cause criminal damage on the directions of the judge.

Earlier this week Simon Levin, 35, from Brighton, Tom Woodhead, 25, Ornella Saibene, 50, Bob Nicholls, 52, and Harvey Tadman, 44, all from Bristol, were cleared of the same charge.

Another defendant, Rosa Bellamy, 23, from Brighton, was cleared part-way through the trial on the directions of the judge who ruled the prosecution had not proved its case against her.

Outside court, campaigners said that they believed EDO MBM was breaking export regulations by manufacturing and selling to the Israelis military equipment which would be used in the occupied territories.

The case is discussed in an excellent blog today by Melanie Phillips. For the benefit of new readers (and some older ones) I should explain that Melanie Phillips is my wife. Indeed, I am married to her. And she is married to me. I hope that clears up any ambiguity in our relationship. But just in case, perhaps I should characterise it as one of matrimony. It derives from a ceremony of marriage. At a wedding. Anyone who still thinks I have failed to declare an interest should add a comment below.

In this excellent blog, Melanie Phillips (still my wife) says that what really jumps out from the Guardian report yesterday is a remark by the judge:

In his summing up, Judge George Bathurst Norman suggested to the jury that "you may well think that hell on earth would not be an understatement of what the Gazans suffered in that time".

You can read what Melanie (to whom I am married) thinks of this remark. For my part, I can't believe an English judge would make a remark like that. I wouldn't suggest he had been misquoted by a newspaper for which I now write.

But please, judge, tell me you have been quoted out of context. Please say you it's not true that, to quote Melanie Phillips (my wife), you directed

a jury to acquit people of criminally smashing up a factory, because [you] chose to believe Hamas propaganda about the suffering of people in Gaza during a war about which [you] presumably [have] no knowledge whatever apart from what [you have] read or seen in the media - a war, moreover, launched solely to prevent Gazans from aggressively firing rockets into Israel in order to murder its civilians, during the course of which war Israel went to heroic lengths to avoid hurting Gazan civilians who were being put in harm's way by Hamas, the true cause of Gaza's "hell on earth".

Tags:
 
Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Share/Save
 
 
 
Dougie Douglas
July 5th, 2010
8:07 AM
This should be great news for all the animal rights fascists and others of a similar ilk. Pandora's box springs to mind

RL54
July 5th, 2010
8:07 AM
Aaah but do you love Melanie Phillips??? I'm sure someone of a cynical nature will postulate that it is merely a marriage of conveniance. Good for you Joshua/Melanie who are both married to each other - allegedly!!!!

RL54
July 5th, 2010
8:07 AM
The Judge may very well be right to say as reported Gaza may be "Hell on earth" but let us consider what the root cause is and how we should react. Didn't the Isrealis once live there, and didn't they leave at the behest of their Government and in a gesture towards the peace process thus allowing Gazaians their own autonomy? Did the Israelis then retaliate against this group immediately and without provocation? I suspect not. I suspect that squalid and infinitly corrupted man (and therefore a prime candidate for the Nobel Peace Prize) Yassar Arafat then directed his troops to start their little game. This has continued under those denizens of peace and harmony (elected by a 110% majority). One just has to look at the Al Jazeera reports of Gaza rockets. This does not mean that Mr Netanyahu is entirely welcoming to the peaceful Palestinians who live under the Israeli influence. Keeping the best bits for his doesn't suggest balance and he should be roundly criticised too.

Natalie Wood
July 5th, 2010
4:07 AM
As an expert in law, perhaps Mr Rozenberg can advise whether the judge has himself broken it by showing judicial bias and misusing a point of law to make a moral issue of a criminal matter where the defendants admitted freely that they were guilty. If so, can be brought before a panel of his peers to have his possible misconduct examined?

NJM
July 4th, 2010
10:07 PM
Ok Joshua, enough with the 'wife' references. The pro-Hamas trolls have gone. No need to feed them here anymore. I'm sure they'll be flooding back when the next "Zionist war crime" happens, or when Melanie (is she your wife?) links to your legal opinions on IDF "atrocities" on "peace activists", while she's shilling for the Jewish conspiracy. Until then - enough! ;) Excellent post btw.

Anonymous
July 4th, 2010
11:07 AM
Using the same twisted British logic i can now go and damage a Mosque suspected of anti-Israeli propa ganda and /or storing weapons ?

Steve M
July 4th, 2010
10:07 AM
Your wife, Melanie Phillips (at least I assume she's your wife - perhaps you can shine some more light on this issue) asks who was responsible for bringing this judge out of retirement for this case. Can you answer this question?

HairShirt
July 3rd, 2010
8:07 PM
Excellent article. And I am a great fan of your wife, too!

Frank P
July 3rd, 2010
6:07 PM
I think that when penning this piece you should have declared a personal interest; there must be many people who know that you are married to Melanie Phillips, even though you have only hinted that you might know her.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
 
About Joshua Rozenberg

Joshua Rozenberg was the BBC's legal correspondent for 15 years. He moved to The Daily Telegraph in 2000, editing the paper's legal coverage for eight years. Now a freelance writer, commentator and broadcaster on legal affairs, he blogs exclusively for Standpoint.

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics