You are here:   Civilisation >  Music > Sweet singing in the choir
This has been especially dire in the Catholic Church, where deliberately misapplied readings of “the spirit of Vatican II” has turned much of the musical practice in liturgy into a pitiful laughing stock. Anglicans will know what the problem is too — those aisle-dancing and numbskull jogging for Jesus choruses, maudlin sentimental dirges, faux American folk music and cod-Celticness. The American musicologist Thomas Day described this kind of liturgy as “a diet of romantic marshmallows indigestibly combined with stuff that grabs you by the scruff of the neck and shakes you into submission with its social message”.

In the 1970s many well-intentioned types thought that such “folk” music and pop culture derivatives would appeal to teenagers and young people and get them more involved in the Church, when the exact opposite has happened. It is now thought that these trendy experiments in music and liturgy have contributed to the increasing risible irrelevance of liberal Christianity, and that liturgy as social engineering has repulsed many. Like most ideas shaped by 1960s Marxist ideology it has proved an utter failure. Its greatest tragedy is the wilful, disingenuous de-poeticisation of Catholic worship. The Church has simply aped the secular West’s obsession with “accessibility”, “inclusiveness”, “democracy” and anti-elitism, resulting in the triumph of bad taste, banality and a deflation of the sense of the sacred in the life of the church.

The liturgical “progressives” who have created this have been at loggerheads for decades with the musicians of the Church, whom they accuse unfairly of being reactionary and Tridentinist. I know this as I have the scars to prove it. During the papal visit to the UK in 2010 there were countless battles behind the scenes about the nature of the public liturgies and their musical content and style. For example, the bishops asked me to write a new congregational mass for the open-air liturgies, and a powerful faction fought very hard for this not to happen. It was said that a classical “art” composer could not have the grass-roots parish experience and “pastoral insight” necessary for — etc, etc.

I’ve given up the liturgy wars since. I stepped back from parish music involvement and now just sit in the pews, suffering with the rest of the Catholic faithful. I still love writing for choirs, though, and from the sidelines I encourage the application of Gregorian chant in simple, vernacular ways, as well as in Latin. The Orthodox chant I heard in Romania in September was astonishingly beautiful. Perhaps there is a way of incorporating it into choral music for the liturgy here too?
View Full Article
Mrs. Kathleen Harrison
September 30th, 2017
4:09 PM
Mr. MacMillan, Thank you for this article. There is an AMAZING musician/conductor/writer in the Charlotte Diocese....Mr. Thomas Savoy....who might VERY well pique your musical interests and give you TREMENDOUS hope for relief from what seems to be an arid desert of musical opportunities lost on happy-clappy music. He is a true talent and GIFT to the Diocese. See for yourself.

September 29th, 2017
5:09 AM
The answer is to take refuge in the Extraordinary Form of the Mass. There you will experience beautiful gregorian chant and sacred polyphony, probably every single Sunday. Yes, the Mass is in Latin but no, there is no folk band in the Traditional Latin Mass!

catherine mitchell
September 28th, 2017
4:09 PM
what are we to do when the priest won't listen to pleadings for the reverence of holy liturgical music?

Steven Hardy
September 28th, 2017
3:09 PM
Listen to the choir of Saint Paul's Catholic Church in Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA. They just released a new CD. They have a men and boys choir that rivals any English cathedral or collegiate chapel.

bahram francis rafa
September 28th, 2017
10:09 AM
Don't give up, Sir James. I am in the pews most Saturday evenings singing the St Anne's Mass which you composed and which is wonderful. We need to dig deeper and discover the deep relation between praise, love and song (singing). We want to sing to those we love and so it is with Our Lord. Folk and pop have a place because this is what the general congregation can do. Sometimes it is woeful. A clearer line needs to exist between hymns and liturgy and in that respect I would really like the great Catholic composers of our time such as you to write some outstanding hymns for 'general' use, if that makes sense. The future depends on a deeper sense of the power of Mass and prayer and a deeper love of neighbour, those in the pews with us. If we can deepen our love for the Lord and our neighbour, deepen our sense of care for the hungry and abandoned then we can deepen our call to God and give greater depths to our music and our desire for deep and beautiful music, deep and beautiful emotions, to send up to God.

Gordon Jones
September 28th, 2017
8:09 AM
For me, James, the most memorable contribution I ever heard to the liturgical music debate came from a senior cleric during my time at Westminster Cathedral: "Sometimes I worry, Gordon, that the music at the Cathedral is too good."

Kieran Maxwell
September 27th, 2017
2:09 PM
I couldn't agree more James. I'm often sitting in mass listening to the 'folk band' and cringing! Please Lord deliver us from this musical genocide!

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.