You are here:   Columns >  Manchester Square > The Wise Orientalist and the Flying Dutchman

One in five of mankind is Muslim. That fifth demands the attention of the rest: often with oil, mostly with menaces, sometimes with violence. There is a certain irony in the terminology still used in Arabic to distinguish between the Islamic and non-Islamic worlds: the "House of Islam", where peace is meant to reign, and the "House of War",  where infidels are supposedly locked in perpetual strife. The Muslim world generates more of the world's conflicts than the other four-fifths of humanity put together. Those of us who are not Muslims are bewildered by the spectacle of permanent revolution, not knowing whether to hope or fear the consequences. But one thing we do know: the West is neither the House of Islam nor the House of War; and we intend to keep it that way.

Two men who have changed the way Islam is seen in the West have recently published autobiographies. Bernard Lewis and Geert Wilders could scarcely be more different: in generation (Lewis, at 96, is exactly twice Wilders's age); in profession (Lewis is an eminent Anglo-American academic, Wilders a maverick Dutch politician); and in perspective (Lewis has spent his long life studying Islam as a religious and cultural phenomenon, Wilders his short career fighting Islam as a political ideology).

One thing Lewis and Wilders do have in common is notoriety. Both men have been marginalised, ostracised and even demonised in their respective fields. Lewis describes how he was held responsible by the media and many of his professional colleagues for the Bush administration's decision to invade Iraq in 2003 — a decision he in fact argued against. (What he proposed was the recognition of a "Free Government of Iraq" to overthrow Saddam Hussein's regime from within.) On the basis of a few meetings with Vice-President Dick Cheney, Lewis was depicted as a would-be Machiavelli, manipulating a naive president into launching the most disastrous war of modern times. Whether it was really so disastrous is another matter. Nearly a decade later, as he describes in his Standpoint essay this month, Amir Taheri found that many Iraqis of all stripes see George W. Bush as a liberator.

However the second Iraq war may be judged with hindsight, one thing is certain: American policy after 9/11 undoubtedly benefited from the fact that Cheney consulted Lewis, a British-born Jew, who had observed the Middle East first-hand since before the Second World War, and was celebrated not least among Muslims for his erudition and insight. It is an indictment of the Western academic world that this pre-eminent connoisseur of the Islamic world should have been eclipsed on campus by the toxic influence of the late Edward Said, whom Lewis vanquished in debate and whose egregious errors he again exposes in his lucid, wise and mischievous memoir.

View Full Article

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.