You are here:   Counterpoints > Tearing Down History

"All the imperialisms of the age" embodied in one man: Cecil Rhodes in 1900

This past summer, many have been captivated by the sorry fate of Cecil the lion, shot by an American hunter in Zimbabwe. Others have been kept up at night by the memory of Cecil’s namesake: Cecil Rhodes, depicted by G.M. Young as a person in whom “all the imperialisms of the age seem to exist in a confused, inextricable embodiment”.

There has been pressure to tear down statues of Rhodes, with the “Rhodes Must Fall” campaign spreading from South Africa to Oxford, Rhodes’s alma mater, the target being Rhodes’s statue in Oriel College, where he studied in 1873. Today’s students attack Rhodes for his overt racism and colonial ventures. These arguments have some merit but we should be wary of attempts to rewrite history. It is certainly true that Rhodes’s conquest of gold-rich Matabeleland (in what is now Zimbabwe) was built on economic exploitation and massacres. At the battle of the Shangani river in 1893, more than 1,500 Matabele tribesmen were gunned down by his private mercenaries. As prime minister of Cape Colony, Rhodes introduced the Glen Grey Act of 1894, which adversely affected land held by blacks. He also disenfranchised thousands of blacks by increasing property qualifications. His language was peppered with the racist prejudices of his day.

However, it is historically inaccurate to portray Rhodes’s policies as a blueprint for apartheid, as some campaigners have done. Explicitly segregationist policies only came into existence in the decades after he died. Rhodes opposed the more extreme policies of the Boer Republic in the Transvaal; his will forbade applicants for his scholarships to Oxford being discriminated against on the basis of race or religion. As always, the truth is complex.

Current opportunities are more important than historic injustices. The Rhodes Trust’s generosity has allowed thousands of foreign students to attain an Oxford education through Rhodes scholarships. He left 2 per cent of his vast estate to Oriel. For better or worse, Rhodes’s funds have been used for progressive ends (Bill Clinton was one beneficiary). Not just at Oxford, but all over Britain, the foundations of many historical institutions were built on injustice. By the protesters’ logic, all of these buildings would need to be stripped o f their wealth or their decorative features.

We cannot simply undo the past; we can only hope to build a more compassionate society. Rhodes’s life needs to be historically contextualised. With the possible addition of an explanatory plaque, the statue at Oriel College should continue to stand precisely because it provokes these important debates. After all, is it not the ultimate justice that talented students from all over the world can now walk past his statue knowing that he is funding their higher education?

Christopher Hitchens
August 29th, 2015
2:08 PM
Richard, thank you for writing this thoughtful article. I think we can all safely ignore Anonymous' (11:08pm) ideologically tired and incorrigible post (11:08pm). Its embarrassingly condescending tone negated any legitimacy it may have had.

August 28th, 2015
10:08 PM
'By the protesters’ logic, all of these buildings would need to be stripped o f their wealth or their decorative features' - No... by retributive anti-colonialism, all that was plundered from colonised lands should be plundered again but this time returned back to the lands to which it originally belonged. I.e. your chinless point about 'build a more compassionate society' is wishful thinking and hopeless conjecture, because not even the current society in which you exist is arguably compassionate. Here's a tip kid: get a grip. Go to Africa and find out for yourself. The 21st century will have little need of hollow intellectual masturbation when so much more can be done. Do more than write sentimental rubbish. Do SOMETHING. Good luck with that.

Post your comment

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.