You are here:   Counterpoints > Cattle Dealer
 

Mehdi Hasan is the current senior editor (politics) of the New Statesman. His previous posts include roles at Channel 4 (where he produced a documentary on Islamophobia called It Shouldn't Happen to a Muslim), Sky News, BBC and ITV. 

The New Statesman has long prided itself on its left-wing, liberal and agnostic reputation. Hasan's appointment is possibly the final nail in the coffin of this image, which has been gradually eroding over the last decade.

In July, an audio tape was released by a leading blog, Harry's Place, of a fiery speech Hasan delivered at the al-Khoei foundation, a Shia centre in London. Much of it is innocuous and in places he criticises the Taliban and urges Muslims to open their minds to other cultures and religions.

However, there are some sections of the speech which have caused great consternation. Addressing an audience made up mainly of young Muslims, he says: "The kaffar, the disbelievers, the atheists who remain deaf and stubborn to the teachings of Islam, the rational message of the Koran; they are described in the Koran as, ‘a people of no intelligence', Allah describes them as; not of no morality, not as people of no belief — people of ‘no intelligence' — because they're incapable of the intellectual effort it requires to shake off those blind prejudices, to shake off those easy assumptions about this world...In this respect, the Koran describes the atheists as ‘cattle', as cattle of those who grow the crops and do not stop and wonder about this world."

Shortly after the speech emerged, Hasan wrote a response to Harry's Place where one might have expected him to clarify that he does not in fact think that non-Muslims are no better than your average farm animal.  No, instead he hides behind the "citing religious scripture" defence, saying that he was merely quoting the Koran. This simply will not do. It has not been accepted as a defence against incitement to racial and religious hatred in UK courts, and nor should it be by British civil society.  He also defends his usage of the term "cattle" by claiming that atheists use similarly offensive language when they describe believers as "sheep".  This is not so much of a defence as it is a confirmation of his own denigration of non-Muslims, regardless of what some atheists think of religious people.

Hasan has not said or written anything which would suggest that he adheres to the core Islamist ideology, and indeed he has rejected the concept of an Islamic State, one of the essential precepts of this belief system. On the other hand, to say that Hasan is a shining example of moderation is to display a very low opinion of what one expects from British Muslims. There are many out there far more enlightened than him.

 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
fredericgeometry
December 29th, 2009
11:12 AM
According to AsimAbbas below, Hasan also refers to Muslims as cattle. Phew! That's alright then. Equal opportunity cattle calling. How progressive of him. The problem is that Muslims are killing each other all over the world because they believe versions of the religion practised by other Muslims makes them "Non-Muslim" -- puts them at the level of animals. And if this is an example of the beliefs of so-called 'Moderate Muslims', we really need to change the definition of what 'moderate' actually means. Attempting to justify it by saying, "Atheists call people names, too!" is so childish at to be ridiculous. Since Jesus is "the lamb" and "the shepard" etc., this is not an insult that has weight; or, of course, potentially violent undertones.

Alberts Nephew
October 5th, 2009
6:10 PM
As an Orthodox Atheist shall I say 'MOO' 'MOO'?

observer
October 2nd, 2009
11:10 AM
'kafirs' are 'cattle'? You should be so lucky! According to Koran 9:28 (Suras 8 and 9 take precedence, being regarded as among the last 'revealed' to Mohamed by "allah"): "O ye who believe! Truly the polytheists (Christians and Jews) are unclean..." The Tafsir al-Jalalayn says that polytheists "are impure because of their inward foulness" and the impure and unclean (najis) are: urine faeces semen a dead body blood a dog a pig a kafir (unbeliever) alcohol the sweat of an animal

Alexander Melea...
August 27th, 2009
6:08 PM
'Get over it' - That's the point, many of us refuse to do just that. Why should I 'get over' the fact that some people are still teaching Muslims that 'unbelievers' are in some way inferior?!

AsimAbbas
August 27th, 2009
1:08 PM
Additionally, having just read Hasan's response to the initial blog, he highlights how he doesn't just call non-muslims "cattle" but muslims as well. Perhaps you should get your facts straight before publishing such piffle.

AsimAbbas
August 27th, 2009
1:08 PM
Why are you regurgitating the same old rubbish? This has been done to death - move on. There is nothing remarkable in Hasan's speech, he is quoting what all Muslims believe about atheists and the denial of the existance of God/ Get over it!!!

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.